Packaging for stratisd 2.4.12021-05-18
mulhern, Stratis Team
For Fedora packaging, we have decided to split out the dracut support into
a separate subpackage,
stratisd-dracut. This package must be installed
in order to support booting from a Stratis filesystem. All other
functionality is included in the
The motivation for this change is to allow users greater flexibility and
robustness. We understand that some users may choose to use Stratis but not to
use Stratis for their root filesystem. These users may choose to install only
Other users may prefer to use a Stratis root filesystem. They should install
stratisd-dracut package, which has a hard dependency on the
stratisd-dracut package also includes a hard dependency on
dracut itself and on
plymouth is used in order to obtain a
password to unlock an encrypted Stratis root filesystem. Please consult
[Stratis filesystem as the root filesystem] for further information about
Stratis support for a root filesystem.
We decided to implement this division due to a problem which would ensue if stratisd was installed but plymouth was not. In that case, the regeneration of the initramfs on kernel updates would fail and render the system unbootable with the new kernel.
The solution of adding plymouth as a hard requirement for stratisd would place an unnecessary dependency burden on a user who did not choose to maintain a Stratis root filesystem. However, without such a requirement a user who had stratisd but not plymouth installed would eventually end up with an unbootable system.
We believe that a separate subpackage is the most robust and flexible solution; it is one which requires no manual intervention by the user.
To properly construct the stratisd-dracut subpackage, it is imperative that the stratisd source code be compiled twice; once with the default features, in order to build stratisd itself, and again with a different set of features, in order to correctly build supporting scripts for the dracut module.
We recommend that other downstream packagers adopt a similar scheme.
Please consult the Fedora stratisd package repository for an example of the packaging approach used.
stratis, the Stratis CLI, will continue to have a hard dependency on
the stratisd package, but not on the stratisd-dracut subpackage.
We would like to thank our users who correctly identified and reported the problems that we have addressed in this and other recent packaging improvements: Matthias Berndt, Vojtech Trefny, and Yanko Kaneti.